Numbers and the church
Yesterday in church our pastor gave a rundown of the previous 2 years and a glimpse at what the next 2 could hold. In his message he hammered home numbers as it correlated to the church growth. I would say it safe to say that most people are often turned off by numbers. Most church leaders state they don’t care about numbers. Our church Pastor openly admits to being all about the numbers and claiming the Jesus and God are all about the numbers. His citation of this is to look at the many miracles of Jesus and the numbers provided in the gospels as they correlate to the miracle. Jesus fed 5,000 with 5 loaves of bread and a few fish, He fed 4,000 people another time, he had 12 disciples. The argument against numbers, as my pastor points out, usually comes from churches or leaders whose numbers are on the decline or never were ascending to begin with. This got me thinking about numbers and the churches and where do I fall in this debate and more importantly where does God actually come down on this.
As I listened to our pastor and his claims on numbers I will be honest it can come off as arrogant, if I was a first time attendee yesterday I would certainly be thinking this guy sure does think he is amazing and likes to honk his own horn. My background in ministry, as brief as it was, I was always trained that numbers don’t matter and when we make too much of the numbers we fool ourselves into believing we are healthier than we may be. We had a long running joke in our youth group staff meetings that if the elders wanted larger numbers to give us a bigger budget and allow us to throw keggers. If you want numbers I can give you numbers, but numbers don’t equate to health. Doug Fields, someone who by all means could point to numbers as all important, once said, “If someone asks you how you are doing, and you respond 57, something is wrong with you.” His point being that numbers do not equate to health and well being, however they can certainly provide context to the health of your church.
To me the reality of the conflict falls in the middle of both groups. I believe numbers are important, I believe that the amount of church goers you bring in every week does indeed matter, I also believe accurately assessing the health of your church is more important than the numbers themselves, and the numbers themselves do not by any means equate to the health of the church. Numbers ought to provide context to the situation they are found in. For instance what seems more miraculous; Jesus feeding 5,000 people with 5 loaves of bread and a couple fish or saying Jesus fed a lot of people with very little resources? Numbers have the ability to express the great magnitude and direness of a situation. Numbers allow us to wrap our minds around a situation and assess just how miraculous the situation is or was. However I would never say Jesus was all about numbers, not because I don’t necessarily agree with the people who are willing to say that, but because I believe Jesus was all about the lost, I don’t ever want to lose perspective of that fact. Jesus came to make the lost found not to blow your mind with awe inspiring miracles. The miracles and numbers were a byproduct of His ministry to make those who were dead, alive.
Pastors who say they don’t care about the numbers are only telling a half truth, obviously they care about the numbers every other Friday when it comes time to cash their pay check or at the end of the month when the lease payment or mortgage is due. I think it’s about time we stop pretending like numbers don’t matter, it also time we stop hammering numbers home as if those equate to a healthy church.
Matthew 18:12-14 tells the parable of the lost sheep and in my mind closes the book on the numbers argument better than anything I could come up with on my own. The parable tells of a Sheppard who leaves his flock of 99 sheep to go and find the 1 who was lost. The 1 lost sheep was a greater responsibility than the 99 that were found to the Sheppard. If your church wants to focus on numbers I pray that its focus on numbers would lay here in Matthew 18, the fact that 1 is greater than 99. The church who believes that 99 is greater than 1 has missed the entire purpose of Jesus’ life and the miracles that these great numbers provide context too.
1>99